Reading the States of Risk in Today's Global Economy
by Kenneth Moyle
October 28, 2008
The current crisis in
international credit markets and the slowing economy have challenged trade
credit insurers. The resulting anxiety among CEOs and credit managers has
increased the demand for trade credit protection to an all time high in the
United States. This increased demand is in part a function of the higher risk
of covering trade in sectors like retail and the construction industry, but also
the success the carriers have had in gaining product awareness over the past
several years.
The global trade credit insurance carriers such as Coface protect billions of
dollars of short-term trade at any given time. Faced with an uptick in claims
from the increase in business bankruptcies and slowing trade payments, the
insurance carriers have reacted to the deterioration in the credit environment
by reducing exposures on the most vulnerable companies and reinforcing basic
disciplines in underwriting new credit limit requests.
All of this scrutiny, as well as the data derived from monitoring global trade
flows, provide a distinctive look into what is happening in the real (as
opposed to financial) business-to-business economy.
So what is Coface seeing from its external analysis and internal data-gathering
on company payment behavior? The world growth slowdown has been receiving less
attention in the news, but it is still significant. Coface expects global
growth of 3% overall in 2008, compared with 4.1% in 2007. All of the world’s
regions, with the exception of Africa and the Middle East, are expected to lose
around one point of GDP growth.
This growth slowdown, combined with the meltdown in the U.S. financial sector,
has triggered a credit crisis that reaches beyond the U.S. and its immediate
neighbors. In Europe, the real
estate bubbles are beginning to burst in Spain and the United Kingdom. In
Spain, the sluggish construction industry, until recently the main engine for
growth there, has hampered consumption and investments. Company payment
incidents, the ability of companies to pay invoices on time and a key indicator
tracked by Coface, have clearly declined. Overdue payments in neighboring
Portugal, heavily dependent on trade with Spain, have increased twofold there
since the beginning of the year. And in Scandinavia, Denmark is vulnerable due
to a fragile construction sector and high levels of household debt.
Credit risks are also increasing in the most vulnerable emerging
countries—South Africa, Vietnam and the Baltic countries—where excessive
imbalances in foreign deficits and accelerating inflation are no longer
sustainable. Years of strong growth in these countries have deepened external
imbalances and stimulated inflation. In addition, households and businesses are
carrying considerable foreign currency debt.
So far, the BRICs (Brazil, Russia, India and China) have avoided the crisis.
Vigorous domestic demand and the absence of any major imbalances are supporting
their performance levels.
From the industry sector point of view, it should be no surprise that
construction and related sectors are the most vulnerable. Other industries to
watch include air transportation, retail, automotive, and specialized
distribution.
There is some good news. Companies went into the current credit crisis with
stronger balance sheets than during the previous crises, in part because the
expansion period that preceded the crisis was shorter. It has been observed
that the farther away we move from a crisis, the more businesses and their
finance managers tend to take risks. A second positive element is the
resilience and growing relative influence of emerging countries that make the
global slowdown less noticeable (1 point of GDP of growth loss between 2007 and
2008 compared with 3.4 points between 2000 and 2001). Therefore, the impact on
corporate payment incidents should be less severe as in the previous crisis.
Could the credit crisis get worse? Coface is beginning to see a loss of
confidence among households and companies in France and Germany, for example,
where the credit crisis has not had a significant impact at this stage. This
could signal that the slowdown could widen throughout Europe. In addition, a
sharp slowdown in China would question the resistance of emerging countries
that has been observed until now.
The credit crisis is expected to continue through 2009, rebounding when the
overall global economy begins to pick up again. wt
Kenneth Moyle is Senior Vice President and head of risk underwriting at Coface
North America, a provider of trade credit insurance and credit management
services.
|